The Fairway Face-Off: Gas Vs Electric Golf Cart Comparison

gas vs electric golf cart

Jumping into the “gas vs electric golf cart” debate is like deciding whether to play it safe or go for the green. I started with a gas cart, which was loud and felt like an old friend, always ready to go but needing a bit of care now and then. Then I tried an electric cart, and boy, was it different! It was so quiet that I could hear the birds and the wind as I moved along the course. It was a smooth ride, but I had to watch the battery level to avoid getting stranded. Both have their ups and downs, just like a game of golf, and choosing one feels like picking the right club for the right shot.

Pros and Cons: Gas Vs Electric Golf Cart

My journey through the world of golf carts began on a sunny morning when I first decided to switch from renting to owning. I focused on finding a balance between a cart’s power and its quiet, eco-friendly features, all while trying to improve my game and avoid shanking the irons on the course. The choice wasn’t just about preference; it was about aligning with my golfing habits, environmental consciousness, and the courses I play often. This decision led me down a path of discovery, weighing the merits of power against the virtues of silence and sustainability.

Gas Golf Carts

  • Advantages: My first golf cart was a gas-powered model, a choice made for its robust power. I could navigate the hilly terrain of my local course with ease, never worrying about the battery running out. The sense of freedom it offered was unparalleled.
  • Disadvantages: However, this freedom came with its costs. Regular maintenance checks, oil changes, and the ever-present need to refill the gas tank became part of my routine. Not to mention, the emissions didn’t sit well with my growing environmental concerns.

Electric Golf Carts

  • Advantages: Transitioning to an electric golf cart opened up a new world of quiet, smooth rides. The lower maintenance requirements were a breath of fresh air, and contributing to a cleaner environment felt rewarding.
  • Disadvantages: The challenge, however, was the battery life. On longer rounds or back-to-back games, the fear of running out of power loomed large, necessitating strategic planning around charging stations.

Performance Showdown

Round 1: Power and Acceleration

My first foray into the world of golf carts was with a sturdy gas model. Its engine’s growl as it conquered steep hills and rugged paths was exhilarating. The gas cart’s robust power was undeniable, a trait I valued highly on the more challenging terrains of my favorite courses.

Switching to an electric cart, I was initially skeptical about its ability to match up. Yet, the electric model surprised me with its smooth, consistent power delivery. While it didn’t have the raw acceleration of the gas cart, it never faltered, even on long days spent traversing the course.

Electric Vs Gas Golf Cart | Winner: Gas carts, for those who crave that burst of power.

Round 2: Handling and Terrain Adaptability

The gas cart’s rugged build gave it an edge on uneven terrains, handling bumps and inclines with ease. Its reliability in diverse conditions made it a trusted companion on adventurous rounds.

However, the electric cart’s precision and ease of handling on well-manicured fairways offered a different kind of pleasure. Its smooth ride and responsive controls made navigating the course a breeze, enhancing the overall golfing experience.

Electric Vs Gas Golf Cart | Winner: It’s a tie, with terrain playing a pivotal role in the decision.

Round 3: Endurance and Reliability

During a marathon golfing session, my gas cart’s endurance was a boon. The ability to quickly refuel and continue without worrying about battery levels was a significant advantage, ensuring uninterrupted play.

The electric cart, while impressive in its efficiency, required more strategic planning. The anxiety of battery depletion was real, especially on days filled with back-to-back games. Yet, its reliability within its range was commendable, never once leaving me stranded.

Electric Vs Gas Golf Cart | Winner: Gas carts, for their go-anywhere readiness.

Round 4: Speed Capabilities

In the quest for speed, both carts have their limitations, governed by safety and regulations. When I was trying to chip in golf with my friend using my gas cart, I could feel it pushing the boundaries and reaching the upper limits of what’s allowed on the course.

The electric cart, while generally perceived as slower, surprised me with its top-end models that could match, and sometimes exceed, the gas cart’s speed, all while maintaining a whisper-quiet operation.

Electric Vs Gas Golf Cart | Winner: Electric carts, especially the high-end models, for matching speed with silence.

Maintenance and Upkeep Duel

Round 5: Routine Maintenance

The gas cart demanded regular attention, akin to maintaining a traditional vehicle. Oil changes, fuel refills, and occasional repairs were part of the package, requiring both time and financial investment.

In contrast, the electric cart’s maintenance routine was refreshingly simple. Aside from battery care and the usual cleaning, it asked for little, allowing me more time on the green and less in the shop.

Electric Vs Gas Golf Cart | Winner: Electric carts, for their low-maintenance appeal.

Round 6: Longevity and Durability

Over the years, my gas cart showed its wear, necessitating repairs and part replacements. Its durability was tested by the elements and the rigors of frequent use.

The electric cart, with fewer moving parts and a simpler operation, exhibited remarkable longevity. The primary concern was battery replacement, a predictable expense that came after many rounds of reliable service.

It’s worth noting that just as you should clean golf clubs for longevity, regular maintenance of your golf carts can also significantly extend their lifespan. 

Electric Vs Gas Golf Cart | Winner: Electric carts, for their enduring simplicity.

Cost Comparison Clash

Round 7: Initial Investment

The upfront cost of electric carts can be higher, a factor that initially swayed me towards a gas model. The lower entry price of gas carts makes them an attractive option for those mindful of initial expenses.

However, the electric cart’s long-term value became evident as I delved deeper into the total cost of ownership, considering maintenance, fuel, and potential repairs. It’s like learning the art of releasing the golf club which requires patience and an understanding of the long-term benefits.

Gas Golf Cart Vs Electric | Winner: Gas carts, for their lower initial cost.

Round 8: Operating Expenses

The ongoing costs of operating a gas cart increased, with fuel prices and maintenance bills taking a toll on my wallet. The environmental cost, though harder to quantify, also weighed on my conscience.

The electric cart proved to be a wise investment over time. The savings on fuel and reduced maintenance expenses offered financial relief, aligning with my preference for efficiency and sustainability.

Gas Golf Cart Vs Electric | Winner: Electric carts, for their cost-effective operation.

Gas Golf CartElectric Golf CartWinner
Round 1: Power and AccelerationRobust power, exhilarating on challenging terrainsSmooth, consistent power deliveryGas carts
Round 2: Handling and Terrain AdaptabilityRugged build for uneven terrains, reliablePrecision, ease of handling on well-manicured fairwaysTie (Terrain-dependent)
Round 3: Endurance and ReliabilityQuick refueling, uninterrupted playBattery anxiety, but reliable within its rangeGas carts
Round 4: Speed CapabilitiesPushing boundaries, reaching upper limitsHigh-end models match/exceed speed quietlyElectric carts
Round 5: Routine MaintenanceDemanding regular attention and fuelLow-maintenance, battery care, and cleaningElectric carts
Round 6: Longevity and DurabilityWear and repairsRemarkable longevity, predictable battery replacementElectric carts
Round 7: Initial InvestmentLower entry priceHigher upfront cost, but lower long-term expensesGas carts
Round 8: Operating ExpensesAccumulated fuel and maintenance costsSavings on fuel and reduced maintenance expensesElectric carts

This table provides a clear overview of the performance aspects, their respective advantages for gas and electric golf carts, and the overall winner for each round.

Which is Better a Gas or Electric Golf Cart?

After countless rounds, numerous courses, and personal experiences with both types of carts, the verdict hinges on personal preferences, playing habits, and environmental considerations. Are gas golf carts better than electric ones? For those who value power, versatility, and immediate availability, gas carts may hold the edge. However, for golfers who prioritize quiet operation, lower maintenance, and environmental sustainability, electric carts emerge as the clear choice.

You can even explore the option of purchasing used golf carts. I used to buy used golf clubs and balls, which can be a budget-friendly way to enjoy the game while still having quality equipment.

In the end, the best golf cart is the one that aligns with your values, enhances your golfing experience, and meets the demands of your favorite courses. Whether you choose the robust gas power or the quiet efficiency of electricity, the fairways await your decision.

The 19th Hole: Reflecting on the Gas Vs Electric Golf Cart Journey

As we park our carts and look back on the fairways we have traversed, the “electric vs gas golf cart” debate feels less like a rivalry and more like a choice between two paths that lead to the same joyous destination: the love of golf. My journey from the roaring gas-powered carts of yesteryear to the serene glide of today’s electrics has taught me that both have their place on the course, each with its own story to tell. Like choosing the right club for the shot, the decision between gas and electric hinges on what feels right for you, your game, and the environment you cherish.

As we sign off on this round, I invite you to join the vibrant community at Golf Ace Nation, where every swing, putt, and ride is celebrated. Here’s to finding your perfect match on the course, and may your game always be as fulfilling as the journey itself.


Q1. Is it better to get a gas or electric golf cart?

Choosing between a gas or electric golf cart depends largely on your specific needs and preferences. Electric carts are favored for their quiet operation and eco-friendliness, making them ideal for short, frequent trips within communities or golf courses. Gas carts, on the other hand, are preferred for their longer range and robust power, suitable for rugged terrains or situations where recharging may not be convenient. Consider factors like typical usage, access to charging facilities, and environmental impact when making your decision.

Q2. How long do gas-powered golf carts last?

Gas-powered golf carts have a notable lifespan, often lasting between 20 to 30 years with diligent maintenance. Their longevity is contingent on regular servicing, which includes oil changes, filter replacements, and addressing wear and tear. The durability of these carts also depends on the intensity of use and the environment they are operated, with harsh conditions potentially reducing their lifespan.

Q3. Is it worth buying an electric golf cart?

Investing in an electric golf cart can be worthwhile, especially for users prioritizing environmental sustainability and lower operational costs. These carts are particularly advantageous for short-distance travel, offering significant savings on fuel and maintenance over time. The reduced long-term expenses and the convenience of quiet, emission-free operation can offset the initial higher purchase price.

Q4. Are gas golf carts loud?

Gas golf carts are known for their audible engine noise, which can be significantly louder compared to the near-silent operation of electric carts. This noise level is an important consideration for those seeking a quiet and peaceful ride, particularly in residential areas or on the golf course where tranquility is valued.

Q5. Do golf carts lose their value?

Like automobiles, golf carts can depreciate over time. Their value retention is influenced by various factors, including the cart’s condition, age, brand, and technological advancements. However, well-maintained golf carts can maintain a substantial portion of their value, especially if they are from reputable brands and have been kept in good condition.

Q6. Is it expensive to charge an electric golf cart?

The cost of charging an electric golf cart is relatively low, making it an economical choice for daily use. The actual expense will vary based on local electricity rates but remains considerably lower than the costs associated with fueling a gas cart. This affordability, coupled with the convenience of home charging, makes electric carts an attractive option for many users.

Q7. What are common gas golf cart issues?

Common issues with gas golf carts include problems with the fuel line, spark plug failures, and carburetor malfunctions. These carts require regular maintenance to prevent such issues, ensuring smooth and reliable operation. Addressing these problems promptly can help avoid more significant repairs and extend the cart’s lifespan.

Q8. Why does a gas golf cart backfire?

Gas golf carts may backfire due to unburnt fuel in the exhaust system igniting. This phenomenon often occurs when the cart is running with a rich fuel mixture, the timing is off, or there is a sudden deceleration. Regular maintenance and proper adjustments can significantly reduce the likelihood of backfiring, ensuring a smoother ride.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top